Is Life Meaningful, and Does it Matter?
If you are an atheist, then you believe each person’s mind is physically separate from all others. And you believe there is no inherent meaning or purpose in life. Whatever meaning we experience is created by ourselves. This is because an atheist’s view of the world is based on a certain way of defining “matter.” For an atheist, matter is something that exists because of what the laws of physics happen to be, and those laws have no reason for existing. They just are. The laws of physics, or of nature, just happen to be there. And matter, which results from those laws, just happens to be here. There is no need to question why any of it is here, since it started for no reason and it continued for no reason.
Atheism is considered scientific now days. But is there any real connection between science and atheism? I am not talking about Intelligent Design versus neo-Darwinism right now, although that is also relevant. For now, I want to just talk about matter and meaning, on the most basic level.
It might be interesting to note, first of all, that the words “matter” and “meaning” are used similarly. We say “it doesn’t matter” to indicate that something is not meaningful, is not relevant. We also say “it makes no difference” to express the same thing as “it doesn’t matter.”
And this is my central point — matter is made out of differences, relationships, vibrations. See what I mean? Physicists now know that they don’t know what matter is made out of. Strings? Matrices in eleven dimensions? What is all that about? No one knows.
But we do know that it’s all waves, vibrations. And what is a vibration? It is simply a pattern of differences in time. High-low, off-on, etc.
There is a philosophy called “digital physics” which is based on the idea that the universe is some kind of infinite multidimensional computer program. Something like this was expressed in the “Matrix” movies, but the idea goes back at least to the 1960s and the early days of computer science.
Of course no one knows what the universe really is and whether it’s like a computer program. The idea seems reasonable to me however. People who believe in digital physics are not usually the same people who believe the universe is Infinite Intelligence — the two groups don’t seem to communicate. But I see obvious connections between them.
Let’s say the universe is ultimately made out of information, and information processing. Well what is “intelligence” if not information and information processing?
I will leave it at that for now, and hopefully it all makes sense and everyone who reads this will say yes of course. If not, we can have fun arguing in circles.
Where I am coming from, by the way, and what I’m getting at, is the idea that religion and science are perfectly compatible. I am a skeptical scientific person, a computer scientist. And I believe that everything is made out of relationships, differences, meaning, and everything is connected.
So I believe that meaning created us and we are meaningful. There is no possibility of anything being meaningless in a universe that IS meaning.
So I am a theist.
Turn, Turn-out, Turf-out
1 To every thing there is a season, and a time to every purpose under the heaven:
2 A time to be born, and a time to die; a time to plant, and a time to pluck up that which is planted;
3 A time to kill, and a time to heal; a time to break down, and a time to build up;
4 A time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance;
5 A time to cast away stones, and a time to gather stones together; a time to embrace, and a time to refrain from embracing;
6 A time to get, and a time to lose; a time to keep, and a time to cast away;
7 A time to rend, and a time to sew; a time to keep silence, and a time to speak;
8 A time to love, and a time to hate; a time of war, and a time of peace.
Here’s hoping Tuesday is his turn…
Read the rest of this entry »
Yes Minister
When I saw this photo of new British Prime Minister David Cameron and Deputy PM Nick Clegg meeting at No. 10 Downing Street, my first thought was “Bernard Woolley hasn’t aged much.”
Amazonian History
While catching up on my blog-reading, I ran across this Megan McArdle post suggesting readers look up their first order with Amazon. I ordered this book on November 10, 1997:
A small story of my mother and I
For a large part of my childhood, my mother and I got along quite well. Compared to her protracted battles with my two older sisters, I was pretty low maintenance. I either had my nose in a book, or was out playing baseball all day, or was out riding the bus to Tiger Stadium in Detroit all by myself at pretty young ages, so when my mother and I actually did things together it was fun for both of us.
The most fun thing that we would do was what I called “the loop” ; a string of small stops at places we could get to either on foot or by biking, as my mother never learned to drive. Some places were only gone to occasionally. There was an awful diner which we went to only when we were starving. The nice neighborhood grocery store was where we would stock up on Polish sausages, onions the size of softballs, and fresh pirogis which were made by a neighborhood lady whom the grocer was on momentary good terms with. Here, as in my sojourns to Coney Islands near the ballpark, I would always get an Orange Crush, from a freezer kept so cold it was almost ice when I drank it. Sometimes we would stop near the gates of the local Burroughs or Westinghouse plants when they would let out for lunch, as my mother knew several of the people who worked there and there was a lot of gossip to catch up on. A special treat was to stop at Truman’s ice cream parlor which had a wonderful zig zag lunch counter and a huge candy case. The desired treats for me? “Nonpareils”, a kind of flat chocolate disk with dots of white sugar on top and red rope licorice. My mother loved Violet Squares ( a lavender scented candy) and butter pecan ice cream. If she got butter pecan, I always got an ice cream float made with vanilla and Vernors ginger ale. ( a true Detroit thang!) You would actually get a float or shake in a paper cone which sat in a metal cone holder, along with the large mixing tumbler full of the drink, so you’d get at least one and half drinks out of it.
We always made two stops in the loop, one of which was the library, where I would load up my wagon with ever more ponderous tomes, books I could barely lift much less read. My bike even had a hitch put on it so that I could tow the wagon. My mother may have started me reading, but she had no interest at all in what I was getting, only that I was getting more and more obsessive about what I wanted our lazy librarians to order and was getting more and more impolite about it.
The other stop was the beauty parlor which my father thought my mother would go to so frequently because she was always, “getting a tune up, like a car.” It is true that when my mother was younger she worked pretty hard to keep her hair dyed red, after Clara Bow in “IT” (so she told me), but really the reason she went was the whole social bonding factor. Every week 4-10 women would go on at considerable length about nearly every personal, neighborhood, or city government problem there was. I was usually the only kid they would tolerate there; most of them left their kids with a sitter. They tolerated me because for an hour or two I would sit and read Aquinas or Engels or Homer and not say a word. When I saw that our local bad bookstore was dumping a clutch of copies of a certain abridged paperback I scooped them all up to pass out at the beauty parlor with a brief explanation. I told my mothers friends that they could solve all of their dilemmas with their slothful husbands, dimwitted siblings and obnoxious neighbors by a proper understanding of Machiavelli’s The Prince. I even went so far as to suggest they imagine themselves as The Prince of the title and to follow his advice as it fit their own lives. Where others saw a work of political philosophy, I saw a self help book.
At first my mother was quite upset at me being this forward in such an odd way with her friends, but she was kind of floored when I had to field questions about the book from them for over a month not to mention explaining the Medicis whom they knew by name…and not much else. So I got to hold court between hair dryers as it were. She still became less inclined to take me there as often…..
Later, one of the women gave my mother back the paperback I had given her, because she went and bought a hardcover copy. Somewhere in my basement I still have that paperback because she would bookmark pages with smeared lipstick kisses, something I still love seeing there.
Happy Mothers Day, Ma, gone twenty years now….
Hail Brittania!
The British people have spoken but we don’t know what they’ve said.
-Paddy Ashdown
- The Conservative Party failed to gain a majority despite widespread dissatisfaction with the economy and fatigue after 13 years of Labour rule.
- The incumbent Labour Party gained its smallest share of votes in almost 80 years, yet still came in second despite polling only 29% and losing almost 100 seats.
- The Liberal Democrats garnered only a tad higher percentage of votes than 2005, far short of pre-election polling numbers, and lost 13 seats (while gaining 8 new ones) despite general expectations of a net gain of at least 20.
Cows Coming Home
I thought the far-flung friends of once-frequent commenter Karen might like to know that I spoke with Karen late last week and that she reports all is well with her. The family is just about completely resettled back in their home, which they returned to a few months ago after deciding not to exercise the option to purchase the bigger farm they’d been leasing. As one of the consequences of returning to their old place is the loss of a regular internet connection, Karen says it is unlikely that she will be returning any time soon and sends her regards to one and all.
Although a heavy snow was falling during our conversation, Karen said spring was in the air and that their cows will soon be back in the pasture. (Karen also asked me to remind everyone to support small family farmers by buying organic milk!)




